Pages

Sunday, February 7, 2010

Peyton Manning the Greatest QB ever?

Is this a serious question? How can a man with only one Super Bowl ring and countless playoff and big game melt downs and disappointments be even considered for this historic and prestigious title? He does bring a lot to the table in this day and age with all the unnecessary coaching and dissecting of the game He does call his own plays and makes great adjustments during the game and picks apart defenses with the precision of a surgeon.


To say that this man belongs in the same breathe, sentence, paragraph, page, or book as Montana, Unitas, Aikman, Bradshaw, Brady, and Elway is ludicrous and down right criminal and finally irresponsible. These previous football icons earned their greatness by displaying the heart and perseverance of what great quarterbacks are measured by. Not by being handed the one Super Bowl that Manning did win with the Patriots going into a prevent defense for the whole fourth quarter. Furthermore either AFC team was going to beat the Rex Grossman led Bears team.


Joe Montana is the greatest Quarterback to ever play no matter what the stat books say because of one reason, four Super Bowl rings along with a coolness and killer instinct to want to win games and win big not to just playing not to lose. Montana was a third round pick that was too short and didn't have a strong enough arm to make NFL throws but even in college he was a winner that snatched wins away from opponents. Manning on the other hand had all the measurables and a heavily talented team all four years at Tennessee and choked constantly in big games and took that trait with him to the NFL.


Yet Montana had to guide his very talented team through the treacherous NFC in the 80's where there were at least 6 teams that were worthy and talented enough to win a Super Bowl year in and year out. Manning only had to take a way more talented offense than the rest of the watered down modern rosters of the modern day NFL, yet he couldn't beat an offense with a great quarterback but no other Hall Of Fame worthy receivers on his team in Tom Brady where Manning has had at least two Hall Of Famers in Harrison and Clarke and possibly three Wayne could be as well. When the pressure was on Montana was at his best and looked like a conductor of an orchestra, Manning looks like a panicked, scared man that's afraid to get hit and just wants to get the ball out.

Montana also took an absolutely no talent Chiefs team to a game away from the Super Bowl after being discarded by the 49ers, Manning would have folded without everything not being in his favor. Montana had to play against defenses such as the Bears, Giants, Redskins, Eagles, and Saints. What was Manning's biggest hump so far Ty Law and Teddy Bruschi? Not say that they weren't good but to compare these rag tag defenses of today to the great defenses of Singletary and Dent, Manley and Mann, L.T., Reggie White, the Saint's linebackers C'mon man.


In closing I hope Drew Breese wins because he is far more worthy of all the accolades that Manning gets.

No comments:

Post a Comment